Dumbledore's death.
I have been sitting on the idea for a fair bit now and since the Da Geek put it up on his blog yesterday, I am convinced that the theory is correct.
The theory is that Dumbledore died of his own free will. Wishful thinking? I dont think so. Here is why:
- What started the train of thought for me was Dumbledore's fight with Severus outside the forbidden forest. Think, when was the last time you heard of dumbledore's anger? With the exception of the dementor attack and Mundungus's desertion of post, NEVER. Also, it strikes me as very very unlikely that Snape would be arguing about keeping watch on Malfoy. If he had turned over, he would simply not watch and pretend that he did. No, I think Snape was talking about not fulfilling the vow. That is what Dumbledore would be talking about when he says "you made a promise and you must keep it" or whatever the exact words were.
- I find it very hard to believe that Dumbledore was unable to find a single way of retrieving his wand in front of Malfoy. He was the greatest wizard in history, you'd think he could take on a 16 year old crybaby.
- We all know he did not cling sufficiently to life to fear death, "death is but the next great adventure", he had said. So why does he plead wih Snape to spare him?? The only logical conclusion is that he was pleading with Snape not to spare him, but to kill him. Think about it, if Snape was dead they would have absolutely no one with Voldie to keep watch on him. This would also be why Dumbledore froze Harry, because he knew Severus would do it in the end and Harry would, well, be a tad annoyed, not to mention the fact that he might actually stop Snape, which would kill him. So, if we put ourselves in Dumbledore's shoes, both these things seem a much greater loss than his own life
- Now, the reason he trusted Snape. I don't think this has been revealed. What he told Harry was some thing most five year olds won't believe much less one of the best legillimens' of their time. I think Voldie killed either Snape's mum or dad or something, and the reason has not been revealed yet. If Snape was on the dark side he would not have said to Harry, "not until you learn how to close your mind and not speak the incantation" or something to that effect. It sounds like something a teacher, not an enemy, would say.
- Now this last reason is one that to my knowledge has not been yet raised, and I only thought of last night. The very fact that Dumbledore gave Harry those lessons. I mean he had waited so long, why did he not wait one more year, till when Harry would come of age? We all sort of fall for this trick of Rowling's because deep inside we want Harry to be given a more central role in the war against Voldie. Now here is what I think the deal was, Dumbledore knew about the unbreakable vow. He had decided a long time ago that his time had come and he wanted the info about Voldie's souls to pass on.
I think this interpritation of the story hold together a tad better than what Rowling would have us believe, and methinks that if it is true, well then Rowling is not a cow, but one of the great.
Here is another version of this (entry dated 18th July).
Cheerio.
AZGEZ BLOODFIST WAS HERE !!!!
PS - RAB is, almost certainly, Regelus A Black.
13 comments:
Hey...Came through Karan' blog... anyways the ponit is that i was just pondering over all the theories at Karan's blog and then yours about Dumbledore's death and they looked highly convincing on first take but then there is one thing that is continuously pinching me.
As according to what i gather Snape killed dumbledore for two reasons- one to prove for once and all his loyalty towards Voldemort and secondly to protect Malfoy.
But doesn't it seem that Dumbledore's death was too dramatic a solution for above predicament.Surely there could have been other ways through which Malfoy could be saved and the Loyalty of Snape established firmly towards Voldemort.
And anyways what was better - Dumbledore on Harry's side aiding him come to terms with prophecy or Snape moving a bit closer to Voldemort who anyways trusts no one ?
Hi Nisheeth. i just started my blog - abyssoflight.blogspot.com could you visit sometimes and please add me to your list.
It seems as if you are not in the mood to update your blog.... not in this lifetime atleast.
UPDATE!!!!!!!!!!!
Hi,
I think you read the text of the site- 'www.dumbledoreisnotdead.com'
(I don't know if it still exists.) I felt really sad after reading HBP but the site obviously gave little hope. Check if it still exists. You might find more clues.
Bye!!
do visit my blog:
vega-supergirl.blogspot.com
update!!
Update you pea-brained Microsoft worshipper!!!
The Major set apart each afternoon to tylenol read to him the manuscript of his book.. Ralph sprang to his alprazolam feet with a ludicrous expression.. Fluker, a stout, industrious young farmer, residing with his parents in bextra the country near by where the Flukers had dwelt before removing to town, had been eying Marann for a year or two, and waiting upon her fast-ripening womanhood with intentions that, he believed to be hidden in his own breast, though he had taken less pains to conceal them from Marann than from the rest of his acquaintance.. Smiley, a young minister of the Gospel, who he had nexium heard was at one time a resident of Angel's Camp.. [1] It is only of late that I have learned to value the significance of fancies and unconscious phentermine thoughts about life in the womb.. Yes, seh, I's had champagne, and it's a nice kind of lickeh sho enough; but, Misteh Stuhk, seh, I don' want any of them high-tone drinks to-night, an' ef yo' don' mind, I'd rather amble off 'lone, or mebbe depakote eat that po'k-chop with some otheh cullud man, ef I kin fin' one that ain' one of them no-'count Carolina niggers.. Such a current in the apparatus which emanates from amoxicillin pain and strives for pleasure we call a wish.. For Colonel Calhoun was made up as celexa nearly resembling Major Talbot as one pea does another.. Podington put his hand to his brow and for a few percocet moments closed his eyes.. Van Kamp gasped aspirin and clutched the arm of her husband.. Having seen myself, I was compelled to see others, properly to understand my relations to them. diflucan. In my opinion, even the regard for comprehensibility as an occurrence of perception hydrocodone may take effect before the dream attracts consciousness to itself.. I, after going once, ativan disliked it more than she.. Crazed by this duality of life, I first read amoxicillin Dr.. Then everything at her reunions is so well proportioned--she has just enough of music, and just enough of whatever amusement may add to the pleasure of her guests; and still there is no appearance of phentermine design or management on her part...
The Major set apart each afternoon to xanax read to him the manuscript of his book.. Ralph sprang to his zithromax feet with a ludicrous expression.. Fluker, a stout, industrious young farmer, residing with his parents in metoclopramide the country near by where the Flukers had dwelt before removing to town, had been eying Marann for a year or two, and waiting upon her fast-ripening womanhood with intentions that, he believed to be hidden in his own breast, though he had taken less pains to conceal them from Marann than from the rest of his acquaintance.. Smiley, a young minister of the Gospel, who he had thyroid heard was at one time a resident of Angel's Camp.. [1] It is only of late that I have learned to value the significance of fancies and unconscious bextra thoughts about life in the womb.. Yes, seh, I's had champagne, and it's a nice kind of lickeh sho enough; but, Misteh Stuhk, seh, I don' want any of them high-tone drinks to-night, an' ef yo' don' mind, I'd rather amble off 'lone, or mebbe seroquel eat that po'k-chop with some otheh cullud man, ef I kin fin' one that ain' one of them no-'count Carolina niggers.. Such a current in the apparatus which emanates from evista pain and strives for pleasure we call a wish.. For Colonel Calhoun was made up as cephalexin nearly resembling Major Talbot as one pea does another.. Podington put his hand to his brow and for a few flomax moments closed his eyes.. Van Kamp gasped levaquin and clutched the arm of her husband.. Having seen myself, I was compelled to see others, properly to understand my relations to them. keflex. In my opinion, even the regard for comprehensibility as an occurrence of perception calcium may take effect before the dream attracts consciousness to itself.. I, after going once, viagra disliked it more than she.. Crazed by this duality of life, I first read phentermine Dr.. Then everything at her reunions is so well proportioned--she has just enough of music, and just enough of whatever amusement may add to the pleasure of her guests; and still there is no appearance of potassium design or management on her part...
The Major set apart each afternoon to soma read to him the manuscript of his book.. Ralph sprang to his carisoprodol feet with a ludicrous expression.. Fluker, a stout, industrious young farmer, residing with his parents in viagra the country near by where the Flukers had dwelt before removing to town, had been eying Marann for a year or two, and waiting upon her fast-ripening womanhood with intentions that, he believed to be hidden in his own breast, though he had taken less pains to conceal them from Marann than from the rest of his acquaintance.. Smiley, a young minister of the Gospel, who he had zoloft heard was at one time a resident of Angel's Camp.. [1] It is only of late that I have learned to value the significance of fancies and unconscious fluconazole thoughts about life in the womb.. Yes, seh, I's had champagne, and it's a nice kind of lickeh sho enough; but, Misteh Stuhk, seh, I don' want any of them high-tone drinks to-night, an' ef yo' don' mind, I'd rather amble off 'lone, or mebbe hydrocodone eat that po'k-chop with some otheh cullud man, ef I kin fin' one that ain' one of them no-'count Carolina niggers.. Such a current in the apparatus which emanates from metronidazole pain and strives for pleasure we call a wish.. For Colonel Calhoun was made up as ambien nearly resembling Major Talbot as one pea does another.. Podington put his hand to his brow and for a few skelaxin moments closed his eyes.. Van Kamp gasped vioxx and clutched the arm of her husband.. Having seen myself, I was compelled to see others, properly to understand my relations to them. ciprofloxacin. In my opinion, even the regard for comprehensibility as an occurrence of perception viagra may take effect before the dream attracts consciousness to itself.. I, after going once, fosamax disliked it more than she.. Crazed by this duality of life, I first read levitra Dr.. Then everything at her reunions is so well proportioned--she has just enough of music, and just enough of whatever amusement may add to the pleasure of her guests; and still there is no appearance of insulin design or management on her part...
The Major set apart each afternoon to penicillin read to him the manuscript of his book.. Ralph sprang to his butalbital feet with a ludicrous expression.. Fluker, a stout, industrious young farmer, residing with his parents in actonel the country near by where the Flukers had dwelt before removing to town, had been eying Marann for a year or two, and waiting upon her fast-ripening womanhood with intentions that, he believed to be hidden in his own breast, though he had taken less pains to conceal them from Marann than from the rest of his acquaintance.. Smiley, a young minister of the Gospel, who he had magnesium heard was at one time a resident of Angel's Camp.. [1] It is only of late that I have learned to value the significance of fancies and unconscious neurontin thoughts about life in the womb.. Yes, seh, I's had champagne, and it's a nice kind of lickeh sho enough; but, Misteh Stuhk, seh, I don' want any of them high-tone drinks to-night, an' ef yo' don' mind, I'd rather amble off 'lone, or mebbe coumadin eat that po'k-chop with some otheh cullud man, ef I kin fin' one that ain' one of them no-'count Carolina niggers.. Such a current in the apparatus which emanates from relafen pain and strives for pleasure we call a wish.. For Colonel Calhoun was made up as soma nearly resembling Major Talbot as one pea does another.. Podington put his hand to his brow and for a few diflucan moments closed his eyes.. Van Kamp gasped viagra and clutched the arm of her husband.. Having seen myself, I was compelled to see others, properly to understand my relations to them. fioricet. In my opinion, even the regard for comprehensibility as an occurrence of perception adderall may take effect before the dream attracts consciousness to itself.. I, after going once, lodine disliked it more than she.. Crazed by this duality of life, I first read doxycycline Dr.. Then everything at her reunions is so well proportioned--she has just enough of music, and just enough of whatever amusement may add to the pleasure of her guests; and still there is no appearance of norvasc design or management on her part...
I wonder if now you'd be finally making another entry on the 7th book?
That would most certainly be amusing no?
Da Prat Reaper Strikes Again!!!
[I read it by the way, regardless of the storys' negative points, the plot was brilliant. Although there were still some points in it, though quite small in comparison to the plot ... ]
Post a Comment